In partnership with

👋 Welcome Back, Case Crackers

On January 23, 2017, Fabio Sementilli, a celebrated Los Angeles hairstylist, Vice President of Education at Wella, and a man known in his industry as "Big Daddy", sat on the back patio of his Woodland Hills home and was stabbed to death. His wife and daughter found his body that evening. Five months later, his widow stood on a stage and accepted a lifetime achievement award on his behalf. Investigators had already been watching her. This week, eight years after the murder, we walk through the full story of how a jury finally convicted Monica Sementilli, and what it took to get there. Grab your notebook.

🔎 Full Case Story — What We Know

Fabio Sementilli's wife and daughter discovered his body around 5 p.m. on January 23, 2017. The 49-year-old had been stabbed several times in the face, neck, and upper body. Investigators initially said two men broke into Sementilli's home and drove off in his black 2008 Porsche 911 Carrera with paper plates.

Fabio Sementilli was Vice President of Education for Wella, a German hair-care company. He was nicknamed "Big Daddy" and was passionate about mentoring others in the hairstyling industry.

The initial story: a random break-in, quickly began to unravel. Prosecutors argued that Monica Sementilli and her lover, Robert Louis Baker, were involved in a romantic affair and conspired to kill 49-year-old Fabio Sementilli in order to collect millions in life insurance benefits.

Baker, a convicted sex offender and former adult film actor, was called to the stand during the defense's portion of Sementilli's trial. He maintained that Monica had nothing to do with the plan to kill her husband. He said he formed his own plan to murder Fabio Sementilli, saying: "I wanted her to be around me and with me more — like all the time."

The prosecution told a very different story. Prosecutors said that Monica needed money and knew that if she divorced Fabio, she would lose everything. They told the jury the only option she saw was murder, and that a third defendant, Christopher Austin, stated that Monica planned the murder in order to collect insurance money.

Austin, who was working as a parole and probation officer dealing with at-risk youth in Oregon at the time of his arrest, pleaded no contest to second-degree murder and testified that his longtime friend Baker told him that Sementilli wanted her husband dead. Austin acknowledged he did not personally speak to Monica about the crime.

Baker fatally stabbed Fabio Sementilli as he sat on his backyard patio on January 23, 2017, then fled the scene in Fabio's Porsche, which was later found abandoned miles away.

The judge said Baker "did not have the intelligence to plan such a brutal, well-thought out slaughter." The planning, prosecutors argued, came from Monica.

Following a 10-week trial, on April 11, 2025, a jury found Monica Sementilli guilty of one count of murder with special circumstance allegations that the killing was carried out for financial gain and by means of lying in wait. The jury also found her guilty of conspiracy to commit murder.

The 10-man, two-woman jury deliberated about eight hours and 45 minutes over a three-day period.

On June 23, 2025, Monica Sementilli was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for orchestrating the 2017 murder of her husband. District Attorney Nathan J. Hochman said: "Monica Sementilli betrayed the person who loved and trusted her most."

Monica's youngest daughter spoke at the sentencing, saying she would not let the fact that her mother killed her father define her. Fabio Sementilli's family also spoke. His sister, Loretta Picillo, said Monica "murdered my brother in cold blood."

Read less. Know more.

Morning Brew delivers the biggest stories in business, finance, and tech in about 5 minutes — with just enough personality to keep things interesting.

Join 4,000,000+ professionals who start their mornings a little smarter.

Check it out

🔔 Latest Developments

Monica Sementilli is expected to appeal her conviction. No appeal date has been set.

Baker pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Christopher Austin pleaded no contest to second-degree murder and was sentenced to 16 years to life in state prison.

Three people are now serving prison sentences for Fabio Sementilli's death. His two daughters are without both parents — one murdered, one imprisoned for life.

🕊 Victim Voices — Remembering Their Lives

Fabio Sementilli, 49 — He was weeks away from celebrating his 20th wedding anniversary when he was killed. He had spent decades building a career he loved: teaching, mentoring, travelling the world as an educator in the hairstyling industry. His colleagues called him "Big Daddy." His family called him irreplaceable. He was sitting on his own patio on a January afternoon when Robert Baker stabbed him to death. The award his industry gave him in recognition of a lifetime of work was accepted on his behalf by the woman who arranged his murder.

He deserved to grow old. He deserved his anniversary. He deserved the truth to come out, and eight years later, it did.

Tip of the Week — "When the Threat Lives Inside the House"

The Monica Sementilli case is another entry in a long, documented pattern: spouses killed for life insurance money by partners who had already checked out of the marriage long before the crime.

Understand what your life insurance policy says. Many policies include a slayer rule — a legal provision that prevents a beneficiary from collecting insurance money if they are found responsible for the insured person's death. Monica Sementilli never collected the $1.6 million policy.

A sudden change in financial behavior is a warning sign. Prosecutors argued Monica was in serious financial trouble and knew divorce would cost her everything. If a partner is hiding debt, moving money, or suddenly pressuring you about insurance, take it seriously.

Affairs rarely stay contained. Baker was introduced to the family, had access to the home, and was known to Fabio's social circle. The affair was not as hidden as Monica may have believed. If you suspect a partner is concealing a serious relationship, document what you observe and speak to a lawyer.

Know your state's financial protections in divorce. Prosecutors argued Monica believed she would lose everything in a divorce. In California's community property laws, that fear was not entirely rational — but it drove a deadly decision. Understanding your legal rights in a marriage can, in some cases, be a matter of survival.

Trust the instincts of people close to the victim. Fabio's family and colleagues never fully accepted the "random break-in" story. Their persistence in pushing for answers contributed to the investigation moving forward. If something feels wrong about a loved one's death, keep asking.

🧩 Case Crackers — The Sementilli Cipher

How to play: Use numbers from the case to decode each letter (1=A, 2=B… 26=Z), then arrange them in clue order to reveal the hidden word.

Clue 1: How many years passed between the murder and Monica's conviction?

Clue 2: How many co-defendants were charged in connection with the killing?

Clue 3: How many days did the jury deliberate?

Convert each number to its corresponding letter, then arrange them in clue order to form your code.

🕵 Truth Check — Myths vs. Facts

⚖ Courtroom Corner — What "Lying in Wait" Means

The two special circumstances: Monica Sementilli was convicted with two special circumstance allegations attached to her murder charge: financial gain and lying in wait. Both elevate a murder charge and make a defendant eligible for life without the possibility of parole or, in some cases, the death penalty.

What "lying in wait" means legally: Under California law, lying in wait requires that the defendant concealed their purpose, waited for the victim to be in a vulnerable position, and then launched a surprise attack. Baker hid his purpose, waited for Fabio to be alone on his patio, and attacked without warning. The prosecution argued Monica was equally responsible for that plan under conspiracy law.

Why Baker's testimony didn't save Monica: Baker took the stand and insisted Monica knew nothing about his plan. The jury rejected that account entirely. Three reasons: Austin's testimony directly contradicted Baker, the financial motive was documented, and the jury found that a man who described himself as wanting Monica "all the time" was not a credible narrator of his own self-contained plan to murder her husband.

What the appeal is likely to argue: Monica's defense team is expected to challenge the sufficiency of the conspiracy evidence, the admissibility of Austin's testimony, and the jury instructions around lying in wait. California appellate courts rarely overturn first-degree murder convictions backed by jury deliberations and corroborating witness testimony.

Where to Invest $100,000 Right Now, According to Experts

Investors face a dilemma. When the S&P 500 finished its worst quarter since 2022 last month, diversifiers like bonds and bitcoin fell too.

Even with the turnaround in mid-April, analysts at Goldman Sachs and Vanguard have projected low-single-digit annualized returns from 2024-2034.

Bloomberg asked where experts would personally invest $100,000 for their March monthly edition.

One answer that surfaced for a second time? Art.

It's what billionaires like Bezos and the Rockefellers have privately used to diversify for decades.

Why?

1. Appreciation. The ArtPrice100 Index outpaced the S&P 500 overall from 2000 to 2025

2. Low-correlation. The postwar contemporary segment has moved independently of traditional investments like stocks since ‘95.*

3. Resilience. A scarce, physical, and global asset class with decades of demonstrated demand.

Thanks to the world's premier art investing platform, now anyone can invest in works featuring legends like Banksy, Basquiat, and Picasso, without needing millions.

Shares in new offerings can sell quickly but...

Our subscribers skip their waitlist*

^{*According to Masterworks data. Investing involves risk. Past performance is not indicative of future returns. See important Reg A disclosures at masterworks.com/cd.}

🗣 Have Your Say – Help Shape the Next Solved Files

We love hearing from our Case Crackers community, your ideas and feedback keep our investigations sharp and our stories gripping.

Which cases or true crime topics do you want us to tackle next? Do you like the mix of features we include, or is something missing? Would you enjoy more behind-the-scenes looks, expert interviews, or interactive challenges?

💡 Your thoughts matter. Fill out our quick feedback form HERE and you might just see your suggestion featured in an upcoming edition.

Together, we’ll uncover the stories that matter most.

🔦 This Week's Must-Watch Moment

You just read about a woman who had her husband stabbed on his own patio and then stood on a stage days later to accept his lifetime achievement award. This week on the Solved Files Interrogations Channel, the crime starts somewhere far more ordinary, and unravels just as completely.

🎥 On August 9, 2024, police responded to a stabbing at a family home in Green Township, Ohio. They found Kenneth Mortimer's father covered in blood and his mother, Barbara, unresponsive on the floor. She did not survive. Kenneth had fled.

What started the argument? He had cut up the family's shower curtain because the sound of running water was stressing him out. When his parents threatened to call a mental health crisis unit, he went to the kitchen, grabbed the largest knife he could find, and attacked his father on the couch. When his mother screamed and ran to the porch, he followed her, dragged her back inside, and kept going. His father managed to escape through the back door and call 911 while bleeding.

In the interrogation room, Kenneth is volatile and dismissive throughout. He describes seeing multiple versions of his parents, claims they "weren't real," and insists he will never go back to a psychiatric facility. Then he makes the mistake that closes the case — he says it out loud, mid-sentence, without realising what he's just done.

He was sentenced to at least 45 years in prison.

👉 Watch "Son Thinks He Got Away With Murder But Made One Mistake" now on the Solved Files Interrogations Channel.

📲 Follow Us Everywhere

Want daily updates and quick case clues? Find us here:

• TikTok & Instagram: Crime polls, case clues, and behind-the-scenes breakdowns.

• Solved Files Shorts: The biggest shocks in under a minute, moments that prove the smallest details can crack a case wide open.

💡 Thanks for following along this week. Every investigation is another puzzle piece, and together, we’re piecing the truth into focus. Stay sharp, stay curious, and remember: the next clue is always closer than you think.